Reusable bottle redesign focus group Fictional transcript for InsightGig practice Study brief A national consumer products team plans to redesign its everyday reusable water bottle. The team wants to learn what breaks the daily carrying routine and which design changes are worth testing. This group explores the problem before any prototype test. The five respondents use reusable bottles at least once a week and travel outside the home most weekdays. The discussion lasts about 30 minutes. Participant codes and all accounts are fictional. Participants P01 travels by train and works in an office. P02 cycles to a hospital and works an early shift. P03 travels between retail sites and sometimes drives. P04 studies on campus and carries a laptop and books. P05 works in a studio and travels mostly by bus. [00:00] Introductions and the last trip Moderator: Think about the last ordinary day you left home. Start with what you took, where the bottle was, and when you first had a drink. I want the trip you actually made, even if you forgot to take the bottle. P01: Yesterday I went into the office with my laptop bag. I poured water in my metal bottle and put it in the side pocket. The bottle was full because the train trip has two changes. By the second change that side was pulling on my shoulder. I knew I would drink at my desk, but during the walk I thought I could have carried half of that. P02: I clipped the bottle into the cage on my bicycle. Weight was the last thing I was thinking about. I carry a small lunch box too, but nothing is on my back on the way in. The first drink was at the entrance to work. I stopped, opened it and drank before taking the bike inside. The cage is a tight fit and that is useful because the bottle does not rattle out when I cross a pothole. P03: I left mine in the car. I realised it at the second shop I visited. I could have walked back for it, but the person I was meeting had already come out. There was a cooler behind the desk and I took a cup. The bottle followed me for most of the day without ever being in reach when I wanted it. P04: I had a laptop, a packed lunch and a folder. I looked at the bottle and decided it was one thing too many. I bought water on campus. The odd part is that I had used the bottle the night before while studying at home. It was clean, full and working. The decision was really about the bag. P05: I put a plastic bottle inside my tote because the side pouch is too shallow. My bus was packed and I did not reach for it until I got to the studio. I remember feeling the bottom of the bag because I had a sketchbook in there. It was dry. I do that check even when I have tightened the lid. [03:35] Bags and bottles Moderator: Go back to packing. What does your bottle have to fit with? How do you decide if you will take it? Tell me what you looked at or felt, rather than the features on the box. P01: My last bag had a stretchy pocket. This one will hold the bottle, but the mouth of the pocket is high. I have to put the bag down to free it. When I bring a laptop and lunch, I would leave the big bottle behind on the days I change trains. A smaller bottle could work because there is a tap at the office. If I did not know I could refill, I might choose the large one anyway. P04: For me there is weight, but also the way the bag closes. If the bottle is loose next to the computer, it pushes the zip up. Then the bag looks like it is about to split and I start taking things out again. A narrower one would probably get more use. There is a drinking fountain at the library, which matters because I can get by with less water in the bag. P02: I would take my current one even with a second bottle on a longer ride. The plastic bottle is lighter than the metal one, but security in the bike cage decides it for me. I borrowed a narrow metal one once and had to keep looking down to see whether it was moving. I would not trade the fit for a smaller size. P05: My old bottle fitted nicely in the side pouch but the top was thin and the bottle tipped out on the bus. I found it before I got off. That made me put every bottle inside after that. Then I care less about a small difference in weight and more about a lid that tells me it is shut. P03: Both bottles I have can go in the car cup holder. A handle helps when I have the keys and a tablet in my other hand. Often I take the one with the handle because I can pick it up while getting out. I would not buy a new one for a handle alone. I still need it to fit the cup holder and be steady on a shop counter. Moderator: So we have a school bag, a train bag, a bike cage, a tote and a car cup holder. When does the problem get big enough to leave the bottle behind or buy water somewhere else? P04: On days with two heavy classes, I leave it. On a day with only the laptop, I often bring it. I can feel the difference before I reach the end of the street. P01: It happens when I will stand up for most of the trip. If someone is driving me I usually take it. A full bottle is not a problem when I can leave it in the car until I get there. [07:20] Refilling away from home Moderator: You mentioned taps and coolers. Tell me about the last time you refilled outside home. What made you decide to use that place? What happened if you could not get water there? P01: On Tuesday I refilled at work after lunch. The storey I visit for meetings has a filter, but it is behind a door I usually have to ask someone to open. If I know I will be there all day I take more water. A smaller bottle is only an answer on the days when I know where the next refill is. P02: We have a cold refill station at the hospital. I use it after lunch, but early in the day there can be a queue of people waiting to fill flasks. Then I use a tap. My bottle sits low enough under the tap to stand straight. The borrowed bottle I mentioned would not stand up, so I could not fill more than about two thirds. P03: I use the cooler if the shop has one. The difficult part is getting the lip of the bottle close enough without touching the spout. Sometimes I have to hold it at an angle with the lid in my other hand. A cup is the faster option if someone is standing there waiting for me. A small change to the shape of the opening could matter in that moment. P04: The library has a good fountain, but the old building I have classes in has one that makes the water taste odd to me. If I am going there first, I fill at home and try to make it last. Sometimes I carry the bottle back still half full because I worried about running out and then did not drink. P05: At the studio I use a tap. If there are ink pots or dirty brushes in the sink, I wait until I can tidy it up. I have used the wrong sink once and the outside of the bottle felt greasy. I washed the whole bottle when I got home. For me refill access is about finding a clean place as well as having a tap. Moderator: Imagine the team makes a lighter bottle with less water in it. What would have to be true for that to help? P01: I would need a refill point I can count on. I'd choose the smaller one for a routine office day, not for a trip when I might run out. P04: It would need to fit my bag. I already carry a small bottle some weeks, but it is wide for its size. I would test it in the bag with the laptop and the books. P02: Smaller water capacity would be a loss on the bike unless it also fits the cage. I would keep a second bottle for a longer ride. On a short day the existing one is fine. [11:05] Spills, closures and confidence Moderator: Has a bottle ever leaked, opened unexpectedly or felt unreliable? Tell me what happened the last time, including where it was in the bag. If nothing leaked, tell me how you know it is shut. P05: It happened about a month ago with a twist lid. I was rushing for the bus and thought I had caught the thread. The bottle lay sideways in the tote. A corner of my sketchbook was wet by the time I got to the studio. The lid looked straight to me when I left. Now I turn it upside down over the sink before it goes in the bag. P04: I had a cap that was fine until I left the little tab open. It was a soft plastic bit that did not make a sound when it closed. I had put a charger beside it and I was more concerned about the charger than the bottle. I got a screw lid after that. I like being able to feel the stop at the end of the turn, even in the dark. P01: Mine has never leaked in the current bag. When I try the lid, I know where it should stop. It needs a proper turn, which takes both hands. On the platform I cannot drink while I am holding the strap and my phone. I usually wait rather than put something on the floor. I would look at a lid I can use one-handed if I can still tell it is locked. P02: The clip on my current lid makes a sound. I pull it once to check after a wash, then I do not think about it. If I was clipping and unclipping it with gloves I would want a bigger tab. I do not need to drink while I cycle, so I do not want a product that looks convenient for that but gets less secure on bumpy roads. P03: I had trouble with a latch that caught the inside of my car console. It opened once when I reached for a charging cable. I used to like the latch because I could open it with one hand. Now I care about whether I can lock it separately when it goes into the car. I would need to see the lock at a glance, because if I cannot tell which side is which I will keep checking it. Moderator: What would a good test of that closure look like? Think of what you have actually described. How would you tell the team it earned your trust? P05: Pack it with paper and lay the bag down. Use it a few times, then try to close it in a hurry. I would want a clear click or a mark that lines up. P04: Try it by touch. If I have to look at tiny writing to tell that it is closed, that is still another check. I would test it with the bag already packed. P01: Try to open it while holding something else as well. Then close it again. I want the two things tested together. A cap can be convenient to open and still make me worry about putting it back in the bag. [15:30] Cleaning and the next morning Moderator: Follow the bottle home. What gets washed, when, and what is it like the next time you want to pack it? Tell me about a day when that process went differently. P01: I rinse the bottle body as soon as I get home, most days. The lid has an inner ring that catches tea if I use the bottle for anything other than water. I try to clean it with a brush, then leave the pieces on a towel. The next morning the ring is sometimes still damp. If I am late I leave everything there and take no bottle. P05: I had a lid with a short straw and a long straw joined together. I could take it apart but it took me time to find the narrow brush. It looked clean until I held it against a light. That bottle got used for two weeks, then it stayed in the cupboard. I would rather be able to see the whole water path and rinse it under an ordinary tap. P02: I wash it at the hospital because it only holds water. I separate the mouthpiece on Fridays, leave it on a rack and put it back when it is dry. It is a habit now. I do not mind one extra part if I know exactly how it goes back. I would not take away the clip to get fewer parts. P03: I forgot one in the car for two days after putting a drink with lemon in it. I could smell it when I opened it. The body was manageable, but I did not know whether I was meant to pull the little rubber part out. I washed the lid twice and used another bottle for the rest of the week. Some guidance would have helped, but I was in a hurry and a less fiddly lid would have saved me from needing the guidance. P04: There is a dishwasher at home. On campus I only rinse it between classes. I think about the lid when it has been in a bag all day and I need to fill it again. When I had the straw cap I washed it separately at the weekend. I would use a plain cap during the week if the plain cap was also safe for the laptop. Moderator: Picture that next morning with the pieces on the towel. What could a design team change to keep you using the same bottle rather than choosing something else? P01: Give me a lid I can wash as one piece, or one where the part pops out and I can tell when it is seated again. I want it dry after a night on the rack. There is no room on our counter for five little pieces. P05: I would test a wide opening that I can actually wipe. Outside size still matters, but I do not need a tall straw cap. The opening has to work under the tap at the studio and the bottle has to stay shut on the bus. P02: I would test whether it is clear how to take the parts out, and whether staff can rinse it at the sink quickly. I think removing too much might make it easier to open by accident. Keep the fit in the cage and the positive lock. [20:10] Compare two directions Moderator: The team is considering two directions. One is slim and light, with a plain screw lid. The other has almost the same size as the current bottle, with a visible lock and a lid that can be taken apart for cleaning. These are descriptions, not prototypes. Which would you try first, and where could that choice fail? P04: The slim one first. It would let me keep the laptop and the lunch in the bag. I would check whether it holds enough for the walk between classes. I would also do the turn-it-over test before I put it beside the computer. If that makes me nervous I would try the locking lid. P01: I am split. The slim one is better for the train and office days. The lid on the other could help with the wet ring and give me a free hand. If it takes as long as the current one to wash, I would choose the slim one and keep it for shorter days. I need to try rather than decide from that description. P02: I would start with the one that stays the same size. The slim one could move in the cage. I would use the locking lid if it still shuts when I am outside in the cold. I would ask whether I can lose a part when I take it apart. If it is obvious how to fit the pieces, I think that change is worth a try. P03: My first thought is to check the cup holder. If both fit it, I would try the lock, because a visible lock would deal with the cable catching my latch. It would still have to work when I am going between shops and I need one hand for the tablet. If it takes several motions, I will leave it behind again. P05: The visible lock. I would be happy with the current size if I knew when it was secure and I could rinse the inside of the lid. I would take that to the studio, turn it over in the sink after closing it, and only then put it in the tote. After a week without leaks I would probably stop doing the upside-down check so often. Moderator: Have any of you made a trade like that before? What looked good at the shop that you did not use later? P05: The straw lid looked high quality in the shop. I liked the way it was hidden. At home the hiding place was exactly the part I could not inspect. I use a more basic bottle now because I can clean it even if I cannot carry it in the side pocket. P04: I tried a huge bottle because it was meant to help me remember to drink. It sat on my desk at home and was good for that. In the bag it was enormous. I would not test it only on a table again. I would put it in the bag with the actual things I normally take. P01: I tried a collapsible bottle. It saved space when empty, but I was always suspicious of the fold. I could not tell whether I had dried it everywhere. A design can solve one part of the morning and still fail at washing. [25:00] What to check next Moderator: If the team can run a trial with people like you, what should they look for during the week? Think of signs they can see and moments you could write down. Then give me one change you would ask them to test first. P01: Ask me which days I took the bottle and what went into my bag. Take one day on a train and one where I work from home. I would ask for the slim shape with a cap that is genuinely easy to dry. A video of closing it would help show whether I need two hands. P02: Look at where the bottle goes on the bike. Ask whether it was still seated after the ride. Look at the number of parts on the drying rack. I would ask the team to test the new cap on a bottle that fits the existing cage. P03: Count when I take it out of the car, not only when I carry it from home. Ask what my other hand was holding. I would test a lock marking I can see while I am getting out. Then test whether I still use it after I stop thinking about the trial. P04: I would write down the days I bought water with the bottle left at home. Record what I was carrying and whether a refill was available. My first test is the slimmer bottle with a laptop bag. Make me fill it, put it next to an old notebook, and then take a normal trip to class. P05: Ask when I did the upside-down check and why. Ask if I washed it that night and whether I knew which parts were dry. My first test is a large visible lock with a lid I can inspect. The thing I want back is being able to pack it without worrying about my sketchbook. Moderator: Is there anything we have missed that would alter your choice? P02: Replacement lids. I broke one cap on another bottle and could not buy the same cap on its own. I would ask about that if the team is making the cap more complicated. P03: A car cup holder can get hot. I do not know whether that is why my old bottle smelled. It would be worth checking under conditions like the ones I described rather than assuming the drink caused it. P01: If you want me to test the capacity, tell me how much I put in rather than just talking about the bottle size. I usually fill a bottle all the way even if I only need half. I could try a marked fill line first. P04: I would see if I drink more in class when reaching for it is an option. Carrying it, taking a drink, and finishing the water are different things for me. P05: I want to know that new parts are available if I lose the seal. It is a small part and it would be frustrating to replace the whole bottle. Moderator: We'll use these accounts to choose what to test in prototypes, including how the bottle fits actual travel routines. Thank you for showing where you would want a change and where you would keep what you already use. [30:00] End of recording